Property Premiums Fell 5.5% as Commercial Auto Rose 5.8%. Pricing Power Is Breaking Unevenly.

Average commercial insurance premiums across account sizes fell 1.2% in the first quarter of 2026, ending a 33-quarter run of increases. The headline points to a softer market, but the details show two different pricing cycles: commercial property premiums fell 5.5%, while commercial auto premiums rose 5.8%.

The key observation is that insurer pricing power is weakening where capacity and competition have returned, while lines facing stubborn claims costs are still holding firm.

The Council of Insurance Agents & Brokers reported that average premiums across account sizes declined 1.2% from the fourth quarter of 2025 to the first quarter of 2026. Large-account premiums fell 2.7%, medium-account premiums fell 1.9%, and small-account premiums rose 1.1%.

Nine insurance lines recorded average declines. Commercial property fell 5.5%, workers compensation fell 3.7%, and cyber fell 3.5%. Commercial auto rose 5.8%, umbrella rose 4.8%, and general liability rose 2.6%.

The Council reported that 72% of respondents saw an increase in property underwriting capacity. Marsh separately found that U.S. commercial insurance rates declined 1% in the quarter. Its U.S. property measure fell 10%, while casualty rates rose 9%.

It was the biggest stock market flotation in history.

It created the world’s first ever trillionaire.

But it may have caused millions of Americans to miss the single most important change to their money in more than 50 years.

Because, while everyone’s distracted by the SpaceX frenzy, Washington is quietly rewriting the rules of your financial life.

It wasn't voted on. It wasn't debated in the Senate. And most Americans have no idea it's even taking place but…

President Trump is replacing the U.S. dollar.

Not with crypto. Not with a digital currency. Something far bigger than that – and it's already been signed and sealed in the back rooms of D.C., ready to be issued by the U.S. Treasury.

Bypassing every legal and political channel under the guise of "national security," Trump has enacted this total money reset using a landmark executive order (14241).

Whether you’re a Democrat or Republican, whether you support this new money or not, it doesn't matter.

Soon, every U.S. citizen will be forced to use Trump's New Dollar to fill their gas tank, buy groceries, and pay medical bills.

Which is why I've produced a critical new documentary laying out exactly what Trump's New Dollar means for your savings, your investments, and your family's financial future.

Detailing three important steps you can take today to prepare – including the name of a core band of assets connected to Trump’s initiative that could surge as a result.

As you’ll see in my briefing, the last time America reset its money like this – under Richard Nixon’s presidency in the 1970s – it created one of the greatest wealth divides in the history of our nation.

On one side, it minted an average of 1,300 new millionaires a day for over half a century. And on the other… the folks left behind, drowning in debt, with no idea how to use America’s new money to create wealth.

As Trump rolls out his new dollar, the question is:

Which side will you be on?

P.S. If you’re wondering what Trump’s new money will look like, when it will be issued, what it means for your investments – all of those questions are answered in my briefing.

This is a pricing-discipline test.

A broad premium decline can mark the shift from a hard market to a more competitive one. But the shift rarely reaches every line at the same speed. Property is seeing more capacity and sharper competition. Auto and casualty are still dealing with claims severity, repair costs, litigation, and medical costs.

The issue is whether lower pricing reflects better economics or simply more pressure to write business.

One key signal is the relationship between premium changes and loss costs. Lower premiums can remain rational when claims trends improve at the same time. They become harder to absorb when claims costs stay elevated.
Another signal is underwriting behavior. More capacity can show up through lower prices, broader terms, or greater willingness to accept risks that carriers previously avoided. The cleaner read comes from whether underwriting results remain stable as competition increases.

A common misread is treating the 1.2% decline as proof that commercial insurance has entered one uniform soft market. The 11.3-percentage-point gap between property and auto shows how much the average can hide.

Another mistake is assuming that falling premiums automatically mean falling profits. Pricing is only one part of the result. Claims frequency, claims severity, policy terms, reinsurance costs, and reserve development still shape insurer margins.

Focus on underwriting spread, not the average premium move.

The useful question is not whether commercial insurance pricing is up or down in the aggregate. It is whether each line is still charging enough relative to its claims costs and capital needs. In a split market, one line can absorb competition while another still needs higher prices to protect its economics.

The first average premium decline since 2017 marks a real turn in the cycle. But the deeper signal is the widening split beneath it. Property is responding to added capacity. Auto and casualty are still responding to costly claims. That makes this less a clean break in pricing power than a test of where discipline holds.

Talk soon,
The Playbook Daily