The Gauge Fell Because the Move Went Up

The S&P 500 gained 2.35 percent on Monday. The index built to measure how much the S&P 500 moves fell 22 percent the same day.

Both numbers come from November 9. The S&P 500 closed at 7,549.94, and the Cboe Volatility Index closed at 19.92, down 5.72 points.

Friday's option prices had put a range on the whole week. Saxo Bank calculated it at about 176 points, or 2.39 percent, either side of Friday's close of 7,376.86.

Monday alone used 98 percent of it.

Coverage read the falling gauge as the scare passing. CNBC wrote on November 6 that spikes like that one have been good entry points for stocks in the past.

The key observation is that the gauge of market movement fell 22 percent on a day of almost a full week's movement.

That read treats the index as a record of what the market did.

The Cboe index is built from the prices of S&P 500 options covering the next thirty days. It rises when buyers pay more for those options and falls when they pay less.

Protection gets bought into falling prices. It gets sold into rising ones.

So Monday pushed the index down in two ways. The move was up, and it came two sessions after the selling without another leg down.

The drop was not even across the curve. Cboe's one-day measure fell 39.75 percent to 17.31, and its one-year measure fell 5.35 percent to 23.00.

The further out the measure looked, the less it moved. The thirty-day number ended at 19.92, still above the 16.61 it closed at on November 4, the day before the selling started.

Do you remember the subprime crisis of 2008?

Wall Street built a gigantic "pyramid of risk" on subprime loans in the housing market.

And then it all came tumbling down, along with almost the entire financial system.

Dr. Martin Weiss says a new $3 trillion "subprime" crisis is underway.

And it's already starting to spin out of control.

This is a size-direction inversion.

An index of movement is priced off what people pay to be protected from movement. Payment tracks direction, because buyers want cover on the way down and stop paying for it on the way up.

The two come apart on the largest days. Monday's 2.35 percent gain was large by size and friendly by direction, and the index followed the direction.

One reading went the other way on Monday. The ratio of Cboe's Nasdaq-100 gauge to its S&P 500 gauge rose to 1.45 from 1.33.

The broad measure fell faster than the technology measure. The selling that set this off was led by technology.

The Nasdaq-100 fell 6.4 percent on November 5 and the volatility index rose almost 70 percent in a day. Monday's rally was not narrow in the same way, and all eleven S&P 500 sectors rose.

THE FEDS JUST CLAIMED

YOUR CASH ISN'T PROPERTY

What if the money sitting in your bank account...

Isn't legally YOURS?

Sounds insane.

But that's exactly what the Department of Justice just argued in court.

Cash isn't property.

YOUR cash.

The money YOU earned.

The money YOU saved.

The money YOU planned to retire on.

Now ask yourself the terrifying question:

If your cash isn't your property... what stops Washington from taking control of it?

Your bank accounts?

Your retirement savings?

The money you spent 30 or 40 years accumulating?

Think your savings are safe?

Think again.

Because when governments become desperate, the rules can change FAST.

And by the time ordinary Americans realize what happened...

The trap may already be shut.

That's why we created a FREE information kit revealing 3 strategies Americans can consider right now to help shield their savings and put more control over their wealth back in their own hands.

Don't wait until Washington makes its next move.

What this turns on

The gap between the volatility index and the front-month future on it. Cboe publishes both. The November contract settled at 20.05 on Monday against a spot index of 19.92, so the future sat above the index. A future below the index would show buyers paying more for cover over the next few weeks than for cover a month out. A wider gap above it would show near-term demand easing further.

Net positions in volatility futures. The Commodity Futures Trading Commission publishes them every Friday for the prior Tuesday. A rebuilt short position would show sellers of protection returning at these levels. A continued reduction would show them staying out even with the index back near 20.

Customer margin debt. The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority reports total debit balances in margin accounts once a month. The figures land in the third week of the month after the one they measure. A fall in the October figure would put the reduction in borrowing ahead of the November selling. A flat or higher October figure would put it inside November, where the next report is the first place it can appear.

Insurance gets cheaper on the days prices rise. That is a fact about buyers, not about risk.

Talk soon,
The Playbook Daily